Short Sale in New York: Owe More Than Your Home Is Worth?

If your outstanding mortgage balance exceeds what your property would sell for, a standard sale won't cover what you owe. A short sale allows you to sell the property for less than the balance — with your lender's approval — and resolve the obligation without going through foreclosure. We navigate the lender approval process for you. From initial lender contact through closing, Inter Realty Inc manages the short sale so you don't have to. Legal note: This page provides general information about the short sale process. It is not legal or financial advice. Consult a New York real estate attorney and a HUD-approved housing counselor before making any decisions.
Contact us

Who This Is For

A short sale is not the right path for everyone in financial difficulty. If you have equity in the property — meaning it’s worth more than you owe — a standard sale or cash offer is simpler and faster. If you want to keep the home, mortgage relief may be the better option. We’ll help you identify which path actually fits your situation.

You owe more on your mortgage than your home is currently worth

You are experiencing financial hardship — job loss, medical expenses, income reduction

You want to avoid foreclosure and its long-term credit impact

You are behind on mortgage payments or expect to be soon

A loan modification has been denied or is not a viable long-term solution

You need to sell but cannot cover the full mortgage payoff from the sale proceeds

How a Short Sale Works

Step 1: Hardship Documentation

Your lender will require documentation of the financial hardship that makes you unable to continue mortgage payments. This includes a hardship letter, proof of income, bank statements, tax returns, and a completed Request for Mortgage Assistance (RMA) form. We guide you through exactly what to gather.

Step 2: Property Listed and Buyer Found

We list the property on the MLS at a price the market will support. When a buyer makes an offer, we submit that offer to your lender along with your hardship package for approval. The lender — not you — decides whether to accept the short payoff amount.

Step 3: Lender Review and Approval

This is the longest phase. The lender assigns a negotiator, orders a BPO (Broker Price Opinion) to verify the property's value, and reviews the hardship package. Lender approval in New York typically takes 60 to 120 days. We handle all lender communication throughout this period.

Step 4: Closing

Once the lender issues a written approval letter, the sale proceeds to closing. The lender receives the agreed short payoff. The remaining balance — the deficiency — is either forgiven or may be pursued as a deficiency judgment depending on the terms negotiated and New York law.
Factor Short Sale vs. Foreclosure
Credit impact Significant — but less severe than foreclosure
How it appears on credit “Settled for less than full amount” vs. “Foreclosure”
Time on credit report 7 years from first missed payment — both
Future mortgage eligibility 2 to 4 years vs. 5 to 7 years after foreclosure
Deficiency judgment risk Negotiable in short sale — automatic in foreclosure
Control over outcome You initiate and manage — vs. lender controls foreclosure
Timeline 3 to 6 months vs. 18 to 36 months in New York

In New York, foreclosure is a judicial process that takes 18 to 36 months on average — one of the longest timelines in the country. A short sale resolves the situation faster, with less credit damage, and with more control over the outcome.

What the Timeline Looks Like

Phase Typical Duration
Initial consultation and hardship documentation 1 to 2 weeks
Property listed and buyer under contract 2 to 6 weeks
Lender review and BPO 30 to 60 days
Lender approval issued 60 to 120 days from submission
Closing 2 to 4 weeks after approval
Total: start to closing 3 to 6 months

Timeline varies significantly by lender. Some servicers move faster than others. Multiple liens — a second mortgage or HELOC — add time because each lienholder must approve separately. We set accurate expectations from the beginning based on your specific lender and situation.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

It depends on what is negotiated and the terms of your mortgage. New York’s Anti-Deficiency Statute (RPAPL § 1371) limits lender ability to pursue deficiency judgments after foreclosure in some circumstances — short sale agreements may have different terms. Always have a real estate attorney review any short sale approval letter before signing. We coordinate with your attorney throughout the process.



Yes. A short sale is reported as settled for less than the full amount and remains on your credit report for 7 years from the date of the first missed payment. The impact is real but significantly less severe than a completed foreclosure. Most homeowners who complete a short sale can qualify for a new mortgage within 2 to 4 years, versus 5 to 7 years after foreclosure.

 

Yes — and acting before foreclosure proceedings begin gives you more time and more negotiating leverage with the lender. You don’t have to be in default to initiate a short sale, though most lenders require documented financial hardship. The earlier you contact us, the more options you have.

 

Each lienholder must approve the short sale separately. A second mortgage lender typically receives a small portion of the proceeds — negotiated as part of the approval process. We manage communications with all lienholders. Having multiple liens extends the timeline but does not make a short sale impossible.

 

Sellers in a short sale typically pay no out-of-pocket fees at closing — agent commissions and closing costs are paid from the sale proceeds, subject to lender approval. We confirm the full fee structure with you before you commit to anything.

 

Start the Conversation

If you owe more than your home is worth and need a way out, the first step is a confidential consultation. We review your situation, confirm whether a short sale is the right path, and explain exactly what the process looks like for your specific lender and property. No pressure. No commitment. Just a clear picture of your options.
→ Request a short sale consultation